Explore Holy Taco

Holy Taco’s 2010 NFL All-Criminal Team

mike vick nfl

Criminals are to the NFL as crabs are to prostitutes. It would be impossible to have one without the other. As it is, they are both unfortunate but unavoidable byproducts of two favorite all-American pastimes: football and transactional fornication.
Because the Prostitute All-Crab Team would be difficult to write, we will instead welcome in the 2010 NFL season by presenting you the updated version of 2005′s NFL All-Criminal Team that I first wrote for the now defunct website, The Phat Phree. Five years is a lot of time for a lot of crime, and the players of the NFL didn’t disappoint. So sit back, relax and see if your favorite NFL criminals made the cut.



QB – Michael Vick
Dog fight vick
Move over Todd Marinovich. Step aside Art Schlichter. Third time’s a charm, Big Ben. There’s a new inmate in town and his name is Ron Mexi… er, Michael Vick. Who better to quarterback the team than Vick? Not only is he a convicted felon but his brother Marcus is racking up an unprecedented string of arrests that would make Ronnie Dobbs proud. Although he’s only a backup for the Eagles, this Menace II (the Humane) Society won’t have to sit behind anyone on this team. Once again, he’s the unquestionable starter… presuming Tom Brady doesn’t murder Gisele before Week 17. And considering there was a shooting at Vick’s birthday party earlier in the year, there’s hope that our starting QB can add to his already impressive rap sheet.

RB – O.J. Simpson

The Juice is an obvious choice, so we won’t spend much time with his legal qualifications for this team. Double-murder, here’s your jersey. More recently, in a case that even Detective Nordberg could have solved, O.J. got pinched for trying to steal back sports memorabilia in a Las Vegas hotel by breaking into a room and taking it at gunpoint. Now he’s doing a minimum of nine years, so he should have plenty of prison memorabilia to pedal when he gets out.


RBLawrence Phillips
A washout in both the NFL and the CFL, Phillips has finally found a team that will take him. Arrested too many times to count, young Lawrence has what we like to call “women problems.” He knows more about “battery” than the the Energizer Bunny. He’s beaten every girlfriend he ever had, and once punched a woman in the face after she refused to dance with him at a Miami night club. While at Nebraska, in what may be his most famous carry, he was accused of breaking into his ex’s room, dragging her by the hair down three flights of stairs, and jacking her head against a mailbox. This also earns him a spot on the All-Caveman Team. But we can’t question his commitment to the game. He’s currently serving over 30 years, in part, for driving his car into three teens after a dispute stemming from a pick-up game of football.


WR – Plaxico Burress
Sometimes when you try to shoot yourself in the foot, you miss and hit your thigh instead. That’s what Plaxico did, and for his crime he’ll be locked up 24 times longer than his manslaughtering counterpart, Donte Stallworth (that’s 2 years for the math challenged among you). Luckily for Plax the NFL All-Criminal team not only allows players to earn a roster spot while incarcerated, we encourage it. Way to go Plax! See you in 2011 (with time off for good behavior).


WR – Donte Stallworth
stallworth nfl

Some wide receivers kill defenses with their speed and others kill pedestrians with their cars. Donte did both, so he makes the cut on this squad. His punishment for the crime? Thirty days in jail and a lifetime driver’s license suspension. He only served 24. The over/under on time until his next DUI: 3 years. We’re betting the under.

TE – Jerramy Stevens
For whatever reason, tight ends in the NFL don’t commit a lot of crimes. However, one night in 2007, tight end Jerramy Stevens got pulled over and blew a .204 BAC. He did 12 days, paid a small fine, did a one game suspension and went back to being a law abiding NFL tight end. It’s not much, but throw in a citation for driving his car into a nursing home and an alleged sexual assault with suspected use of the date rape drug, and he’s more than welcome on our squad.


OL – Richard Collier
To make this roster, you ordinarily have to do a lot more than the usual DUI or girlfriend/spouse/baby mama abuse. However, Collier sneaks onto the team not for his DUI, but how he got his DUI: found asleep behind the wheel at a McDonald’s drive-thru window. How wasted was he if he passed out before getting his food? I’m lovin’ it! What I’m not lovin’ is that less than a year later he was shot 14 times and was paralyzed from the waist down, ending his NFL career. Still, he’ll always have a starting spot right here on the NFL All-Criminal Team…even though his left leg was amputated.


OL – Cornell Green
Green was arrested last year for allegedly slamming the mother of his two kids against the wall and, here’s the kicker, hitting her with a mop handle. Slamming a baby mama against a wall is standard fare in the NFL, but add the mop handle beating, and you know he must be a Raider. Well, he’s a Bill now, but he was with Oakland at the time.


OL – Nate Newton
Newton was a shoe-in for this team when he got busted in Louisiana with 213 pounds of marijuana after being pulled over for a traffic violation (who breaks traffic laws with a van full of drugs?), but then he made a serious case to become a team captain six weeks later when, while out on bail, he got busted again. This time it was 175 pounds of marijuana in the trunk of his car. One thing’s for sure – when it’s fourth and long, we know ol’ Nate is down to ‘go for it’.


OL – Justin Strzelczyk
strzelczyk car crash
Aside from only having one vowel in his last name (not counting “y”), Strzelczyk also had only one great defining moment. After a hit-and-run accident in New York, police chased his pickup 40 miles, during which Strzelczyk flipped off troopers and, at one point, threw a beer bottle at them. In the end, Strzelczyk crashed head on at 90 miles per hour into a tanker truck carrying corrosive acid, leaving an explosive scene police compared to an airplane crash. Strzelczyk didn’t make it out alive, but he did, literally, go down in a “blaze of glory,” and you gotta respect that. And for those concerned, the driver of the tanker escaped with only minor injuries.


OL – Barret Robbins
Previously best known for disappearing the night before Oakland’s Super Bowl thrashing in 2003, Robbins trumped that the following year by attacking three police officers who, being armed, shot him twice in the chest. Police reports indicate that even after being shot, Robbins continued to attack the officers, which is just the kind of spunk we need on this team. Facing three counts of attempted murder of a police officer, he took a plea bargain. Since then he’s been in and out of jail and rehab, but we feel this team will give him the structure he so desperately needs. 


LB – Ray Lewis
ray lewis
Following a Super Bowl party in 2000, Lewis was arrested on two counts of first-degree murder. The charges were later dropped, and Lewis plead guilty to a misdemeanor charge of obstruction of justice. Despite this, Lewis did pay out undisclosed amounts to relatives of the victims, which is not something that innocent people tend to do. His image has recovered quite a bit since the incident, and earlier this year, a portion of Baltimore’s North Avenue was renamed "Ray Lewis Way." Considering Baltimore’s murder rate, we feel Ray-Ray was a fitting choice.


LB – Lawrence Taylor
LT rape
L.T. went from cracking heads to crack head in record time. He’s had numerous drug related arrests along with a tax evasion charge. Regarding his lifestyle in the late 1990s, Taylor described his home as “like a crack house.” In his now infamous “60 Minutes” interview, Taylor claimed to have spent thousands of dollars a day on narcotics and to have hired prostitutes to go to opponents’ hotel rooms the night before games. Apparently, he also hires them to go to his own room, since earlier this year he was charged with the statutory rape of a 16-year-old call girl.


LB – Bill Romanowski
Romanowski was indicted by a grand jury in 2000 for allegedly obtaining phentermine, a diet drug with stimulant properties, under false pretenses. He was later acquitted but was also linked to the BALCO steroid scandal. He broke the orbital bone of teammate Marcus Williams in practice and effectively ended his career. He’s been fined for numerous violent on-field incidents and spat in the face of wide receiver J.J. Stokes on Monday Night Football.


DL – Alonzo Spellman
Spellman is the only member of this team to have been charged with terrorizing passengers on a commercial flight and forcing an emergency landing. According to investigators, once on the ground Spellman told the pilot “I am about to rip your throat out.” Add to the mix weapons charges, a standoff with police from inside his publicist’s home and the usual DUI and failure to appear charges, and you’ve got a starting D-lineman.


DL – Darrell Russell
A repeat offender of the NFL’s substance abuse policy, Russell actually broke it so many times that he ended up out of football. His weakness? Ecstasy. Perhaps that’s what drove Russell to be charged with 25 felonies as an accomplice stemming from the videotaped rape of a woman by two of his friends. Prosecutors alleged that he was the one behind the camera, but later dropped charges due to concern they would not win a jury conviction. Finally, Russell’s substance abuse drove him and a former USC teammate into a fire hydrant and a parked bus, ending his run on this earth, but cementing his place on this team for all eternity.

DE – Terry “Tank” Johnson
tank johnson
When your Wikipedia entry has a section titled “Legal Troubles,” and it takes up over 75% of the page (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tank_Johnson) you can bet that you’ll have a spot on this roster. Basically, Tank likes guns…a lot. And he hates to register them. But he likes leaving them loaded in homes with children present. He also likes confronting officers of the law, driving while impaired and hiring bodyguards that get murdered. For all of those reasons, Tank makes the cut, even if he was cut by the bears.

DE – Leonard Little
Ol’ Leonard Little turned 24, worked up a .19 BAC (coincidentally on October 19th) and drove his Lincoln Navigator right through a red light and into the car of Susan Gutweiler, mother of two. He did 90 days in jail and took an eight game suspension, then went on with his life (unlike Gutweiler). Did he at least learn his lesson? Nope. In 2004 he got busted again for drunk driving, failing no less than three roadside sobriety tests. However, he somehow beat the rap and was only convicted of a misdemeanor speeding charge. Our kind of player.


S – Gene Atkins
Gene was arrested for firebombing a former business associate but was later acquitted. Most recently he barricaded himself in his house after his wife called police claiming he had shoved her against a wall, choked her, bit her and then beat her with a remote control. Then, when told by police that he was under arrest, Atkins replied, “No I’m not” and punched the officer in the throat, then pushed him outside the home. Surprisingly the police didn’t agree, re-entered the home, found Atkins holding four knives, and summarily dropped him with a ‘hot shot’ from a Taser gun. He currently claims to be suffering from dementia as the result of all the hits he took in the NFL.  


S – Eugene Robinson
On the eve of the Super Bowl and a mere twelve hours after receiving the Bart Starr Award from Athletes in Action, an award honoring high moral character, Robinson was busted for offering an undercover Miami policewoman $40 for oral sex. While his record is otherwise spotless, the sheer publicity this arrest generated warrants a starting spot in our secondary. Plus, he’s the only guy that God will allow to do the team prayer.


CB – Adam “Pacman” Jones
nfl pacman jones
The question isn’t what has Pacman done to make it on this team, the question is what hasn’t he done to make the squad? When he goes out to strip clubs (or as he illiterately calls them, “script clubs”) strippers get their heads slammed into the stage and bystanders tend to get murdered. When he drives, he makes sure to be wasted and super high so that when he exceeds the speed limit he knows it won’t be by just a little bit. He has embarrassed himself as a wrestler and a rapper, and has shown no indication of altering his decision making any time soon. We can’t wait to see what the future, as short as it may be, brings for our All-Star Criminal cornerback!


CB – Corey Fuller
One of the few players on this team not arrested for fighting outside a bar, beating, raping or killing a woman or any sort of narcotics charge, Fuller seems out of place on this team. He was however charged with hosting high-stakes card games at his house, which was also the site of a shootout. In that event, an assailant attempted to rob the card game and a shootout ensued in which approximately 20 rounds were fired between Fuller and the man. Although only feelings were hurt in the end, that’s still some Wild West shit. It definitely earns Fuller a spot at cornerback.


Special Teams

PK – Jeff Reed
kicker jeff reed
Reed was cited for criminal mischief and disorderly conduct after throwing a temper tantrum in a convenience store restroom. His crime? He damaged a towel dispenser after finding it empty. Seriously. Then, as if he hadn’t done enough to reaffirm the stereotype that all kickers are pussies, he pled guilty and paid a fine. You gotta fight that shit man! In 2009 he was cited for public intox, which is a step in the right direction.

P – Todd Sauerbrun
Punters are not exactly known to be the criminal type, but with a DUI to his name, Sauerbrun stands out as the most rebellious of the bunch. And to top it all off, he was also charged with driving with a revoked license, proving this punter is bad to the bone. Throw in an arrest after an altercation with a Taxi driver, and you’ve got yourself our starting punter. In a hilarious aside, he has a running feud with the Gramatica family. Martin, Bill and even baby brother Santiago are all players he refuses to share a uniform with. No worries, Todd, unless one of them holds up a Dairy Queen, it’ll be just you and Jeff Reed.


QB – Todd Marinovich

Todd was once arrested in a public bathroom with a bent spoon and a syringe. What better guy to lead this team? The closest most quarterbacks come to getting in trouble with the law is a DUI, but Marinovich doesn’t fuck around. The space between his toes has seen more needles than a Christmas tree lot. Just don’t tell him to “put the smack down” because he never will.

WR – Rae Carruth
Convicted of the most heinous crime in the history of the NFL (remember, OJ was found innocent), Carruth is an obvious choice. He orchestrated an execution-style murder of his pregnant girlfriend because she refused to have an abortion. While he only got into the endzone four times in his short career, you can rest assured that this wideout has been on the receiving end of numerous scoring drives since arriving in a state correctional facility.
WR – Michael Irvin
Michael Irvin
With all the cocaine he’s done in his life he could probably chalk an entire football field. He kept the Dallas courtrooms busy in the late 90’s and despite finding God, he still managed to mix in a few drug charges in this millennium too. His roster spot is further solidified by the fact that he once had a hit out on him – by a cop. Former Dallas police officer Johnnie Hernandez was arrested after he paid $2960 to an undercover DEA agent in order to have Irvin murdered. Despite his image being rehabilitated by his stint on “Dancing with the Stars,” he was recently sued in civil court for an alleged sexual assault. Still got it, Mike!
DE – Jim Dunaway
Charged with murder in the death of his former wife, Dunaway is the unpublicized OJ Simpson. Prior to her death, she had won a divorce judgment that gave her more than 800 acres the couple owned, $1,800 a month in alimony and half of Dunaway’s NFL pension. A grand jury assigned to the case did not indict him (“if you didn’t see them fight, you must not indict”). His kids then sued him in a civil suit and won.
K – Sebastian Janikowski
He’s been arrested for bar fights, drinking and driving (.20 BAC), reckless driving, bribing a police officer, evidence tampering and possession of a drug best known in the media as “the date rape drug.” Oh, and one more thing – he’s a kicker. It should also be noted that in a position that usually features the most diminutive guys on the field Janikowski stands 6’2 and weighs 250. In his defense a bar owner once said of him, “It’s his Polish accent, he always sounds wasted.” That, or is his always wasted. My money’s on the latter.
Coach – Jimmy Johnson
coach jimmy johnson
Seeing as how he’s already coached half this team, he’s the obvious choice for the job. Whether you’re looking at his days at the University of Miami or with the Dallas Cowboys, this guy has never met a criminal he wouldn’t put in the starting lineup. While he has never been charged with a crime, he has been known to associate with individuals that could best be described as unsavory. And with a little luck, maybe he’ll be convicted of fraud for peddling dick-extending pills. Only time, will tell.

22 Responses to "Holy Taco’s 2010 NFL All-Criminal Team"

  1. wozen dutz says:

    What about Lance Rentzel? Exposing yourself to a 10-year-old should be enough to get you on the squad?

  2. Lockdown D says:

    Dude, no Rae Carruth? Come on. That guy had his girlfriend murdered!!!

  3. Klingon Kunt Shave says:

    where is dave meggett? all that guy does is rape women.

  4. Dave Meggett says:

    Hey mutha, I also rape kickers too. Check yo facts, bitch!

  5. BSK says:

    Amazing how much “extra credit” you gave to black players. Well played.

  6. Jame Gumb says:
    I forgive you. As for the other guy, he’s been on it in years past. This year we cut him.
  7. Danno says:

    Ooops, just noticed Carruth on the bench.

  8. BigNutz4U says:

    Come on where is the owner of this all-star Penal team? Give credit where credit is due and put Al Davis on this list of misfits!

  9. dildos says:

    Awww, for me? You DO care!

  10. moshmosh says:

    No Ben Roethlisberger? come on. He definitely deserved a spot on the roster.

  11. dildos says:

    Yeah that’s some bullshit that he wasn’t even mentioned. Multiple accusations of rape. One where he had his goddamn body guard keep a girl in the mens rest room!

  12. Jame Gumb says:
    He was clearly mentioned under the QB position, the first position listed. I went ahead and bolded and underlined it for you.
  13. pratik says:

    I would be satisfied by one article like this every day instead of an endless parade of idiocy like there’s been for the past few weeks.

  14. Anonymous IV says:

    ^ LOL

  15. There must be a lot of quarterbacks to choose from cause you didn’t go with Big Ben.

  16. Hugh Jassole says:

    Ah ha ha ha! And all u fuqn sporto’s support these dick heads! Give em some more money eh!?!?

    Oh ya. FIRST

  17. Suspicious says:

    I find it impossible to believe that Holy Taco would actually put this much research into an article.

  18. Zoo Jing says:

    Wow, you have to admit that is pretty cool dude.


  19. Danno says:

    Good list, but you’re missing Mark Chmura (fucked his 17 year old babysitter) at tight end, and Rae Carruth (hired a hitman to kill his pregnant girlfriend – though the kid survived) at wide out. Carruth definitely deserves the nod over Plax and Stallworth, though Chmura was acquitted despite admitting the sex, so it’s a tossup there.